Healthiir

Plant milks compared: soy, oat, almond, coconut and rice

Plant milk comparison per cup from USDA data: protein, calcium and sugars in soy, oat, almond, coconut and rice milk, fortification, labels and cooking uses.

10 min read Updated October 29, 2026
Watercolor illustration of lentils, chickpeas, tofu, nuts, seeds and greens
Illustration (AI-generated), not a photograph.

Plant milks are made by blending soybeans, oats, nuts, rice or coconut with water, straining and often fortifying the result. They pour like milk and often sit next to it in the store, but nutritionally they are different from each other and from dairy milk. The base ingredient sets the protein, fat and natural carbohydrate; the manufacturer decides the calcium, vitamin D, vitamin B12 and added sugar. That makes the label the most important thing on the carton.

Per cup, from USDA data

The table compares one cup of each common plant milk, calculated from USDA FoodData Central records, with a cup of 2% dairy milk for reference. The coconut row is the carton beverage for drinking, not the thick canned coconut milk used in curries, and USDA’s generic record for it is a sweetened product fortified with calcium and vitamins A, B12 and D2. The oat and rice records are USDA’s generic survey records, which do not say whether the product was sweetened. An unfortified soy milk is included to show what fortification adds, and sweetened soy and almond milks to show what sweetening adds.

FoodAmountCaloriesProteinFatSat. fatCarbsTotal sugarsCalciumUSDA record
Soy milk, unsweetened1 cup (244 g)938.7 g5.2 g0.8 g3.1 g1.4 g246 mgFDC 2705405
Soy milk, original or vanilla, unfortified1 cup (243 g)1317.9 g4.3 g0.5 g15 g9.7 g61 mgFDC 172446
Soy milk, sweetened1 cup (244 g)1298.3 g5.0 g0.7 g13 g11 g237 mgFDC 2705404
Oat milk (generic record)1 cup (244 g)1101.6 g5.7 g0.5 g13 g5.0 g378 mgFDC 2705412
Almond milk, unsweetened1 cup (244 g)371.3 g3.0 g0.3 g0.8 g0.0 g422 mgFDC 2705409
Almond milk, sweetened1 cup (244 g)731.3 g2.9 g0.2 g11 g9.7 g405 mgFDC 2705407
Coconut milk beverage, sweetened, fortified (carton)1 cup (240 g)740.5 g5.0 g5.0 g7.0 g6.0 g451 mgFDC 174116
Rice milk (generic record)1 cup (244 g)1150.7 g2.4 g0.0 g22 g13 g288 mgFDC 2705411
Dairy milk, 2% (for reference)1 cup (244 g)1228.2 g4.6 g2.7 g12 g12 g307 mgFDC 2705386

Calculated from USDA FoodData Central: the nutrient values per 100 g of each record, scaled to the gram weight USDA lists for the amount shown. Brands and varieties differ.

What the table shows

  • Protein. Soy milk is the only plant milk in the table with protein in the same range as dairy milk. Oat, almond, coconut and rice milks are low in protein, so if you drink one of them, the protein in your meals has to come from elsewhere.
  • Carbohydrate and sugars. Rice milk carries the most carbohydrate and sugars of the plant milks. Sweetening matters more than the base: the sweetened soy and almond rows carry far more sugars than their unsweetened versions, and the unfortified soy record, which covers original and vanilla styles, sits with them. The generic oat milk record carries more carbohydrate than unsweetened soy or almond milk, since its base is a grain. The table cannot tell you how much of the sugar was added; on a carton, the Added Sugars line does. Unsweetened almond and soy milk are the lowest.
  • Fat. Almost all the fat in the coconut beverage is saturated; in the soy, oat and almond milks, saturated fat is a small part of the total.
  • Calcium. The unfortified soy milk shows a fraction of the calcium of every other milk in the table, which is the clearest sign that the high figures in the other plant milk rows come from fortification. Vitamin D and B12, which this table does not show, also depend on what the maker adds.

The figures describe the specific records in USDA’s database; any carton on the shelf can differ. For why two databases or a database and a label can disagree, see this note on why food databases differ.

Which plant milk for which need

There is no single best plant milk; there is a best one for a job. A summary of the table and the sections below:

If you wantChooseWhy
The most proteinUnsweetened soy milkThe only milk in the USDA table with protein in dairy milk’s range
The fewest caloriesUnsweetened almond milkThe lowest calories and carbohydrate in the table
Creaminess in coffee and porridgeOat milk, or a “barista” styleBody from the oats; barista versions are made not to separate in hot coffee
A stand-in for dairy in the dietAny fortified milk, ideally soyCalcium, vitamin D and B12 come from fortification; soy also brings protein
No soy and no nutsOat or rice milkCheck the label for added ingredients; choose certified gluten-free oats for celiac disease
Baking and savory saucesUnsweetened, unflavored soy or oat milkProtein and body for browning and thickening; no vanilla in the gravy
The least added sugarAnything labeled unsweetenedCompare the Added Sugars line, not the front of the carton

Soy milk vs oat milk

The two most common choices differ most on protein and carbohydrate. In the USDA records, unsweetened soy milk has several times the protein of oat milk and less carbohydrate, while oat milk tastes slightly sweet and creamy and is the one most people prefer in coffee. Both are usually fortified, and both bake well. If you drink a glass a day as a protein source, soy is the better fit; if you want a creamy, neutral milk for coffee and cereal and get protein elsewhere, oat milk does the job.

Pea, hemp and cashew milks

USDA FoodData Central has no generic records for these newer milks, so they are not in the table. Pea milk is made from isolated pea protein, so its protein content is set by the manufacturer and is often far higher than oat or almond milk; hemp milk, made from hemp seeds, has an earthy flavor; cashew milk is creamy and mild. For all three, the Nutrition Facts panel is the only reliable source for protein, calcium, vitamin D and added sugar.

Fortification: calcium, vitamin D, B12 and iodine

Calcium

The NIH Office of Dietary Supplements (ODS) names “milk substitutes (e.g., soy and almond beverages)” among the foods fortified with calcium in the United States and lists calcium-fortified soymilk at 299 mg per cup (23 %DV). That is a different figure from the unsweetened soy milk row in the USDA table above, because the two describe different products: the ODS row is a calcium-fortified soymilk, the USDA row a generic survey record, and cartons differ again. The FDA Daily Value for calcium is 1,300 mg. Added calcium can settle at the bottom of the carton, so shake it well before pouring, or the last glass gets more than its share. For the full picture of non-dairy calcium, including calcium-set tofu and greens, see calcium without dairy.

Vitamin D

The ODS writes: “Plant milk alternatives (such as beverages made from soy, almond, or oats) are often fortified with similar amounts of vitamin D to those in fortified cow’s milk (about 3 mcg [120 IU]/cup); the Nutrition Facts label lists the actual amount.” Its food table lists vitamin D-fortified soy, almond and oat milks at 2.5-3.6 mcg (100-144 IU) per cup (13-18 %DV). The FDA requires vitamin D on every Nutrition Facts label, so it is easy to compare.

Vitamin B12

Some plant milks have vitamin B12 added (the USDA coconut beverage record in the table is one) and others do not. B12 is not among the nutrients the FDA requires on every Nutrition Facts label; the FDA says “other vitamins and minerals may be listed voluntarily by the manufacturer.” If you count on your plant milk as part of your B12 intake, confirm it on the panel; the guide to vitamin B12 for vegans explains how much you need and the other sources.

Iodine

Iodine is a gap that labels rarely show: the FDA does not require food labels to list iodine unless iodine has been added to the food. According to the ODS, “Plant-based beverages used as milk substitutes, such as soy and almond beverages, contain relatively small amounts of iodine.” Its table lists a cup of soy beverage at 3 mcg, 2% of the Daily Value, against an adult RDA of 150 mcg. Someone who replaces dairy milk with a plant milk is replacing a food that the ODS counts among “the best sources of iodine” with one that supplies little, so iodine needs another source. The Scientific Foundation for the 2025-2030 Dietary Guidelines says “A modest daily iodine supplement of about 150 micrograms, or consistent use of iodized salt, helps maintain adequacy in a vegan or vegetarian diet.” A doctor or registered dietitian can help if you are pregnant or breastfeeding, when iodine needs are higher.

What the label can say: FDA’s draft guidance

In February 2023 the FDA published draft guidance on labeling plant-based milk alternatives. Its key recommendation is that products using the term “milk” in their name, and whose nutrient composition differs from milk, “bear an additional nutrient statement on the product label describing how it is nutritionally different.” The FDA’s example reads: “Contains lower amounts of [nutrient name(s)] than milk.” The guidance stresses that “The use of these statements is voluntary,” and as of October 2026 the FDA’s guidance page still lists the document as a draft, “Not for implementation.”

The same draft says a plant-based milk alternative “may be labeled with the term ‘beverage,’ ‘drink,’ or ‘milk,’” and that “the term ‘dairy-free milk’ is not an adequate name for any plant-based milk alternative because it does not describe the nature of the plant-source.” In other words, the draft expects the name to say what the drink is made from: soy, oat, almond and so on.

Plant milks and the dairy group

The two most recent editions of the Dietary Guidelines for Americans handle plant milks differently.

  • 2020-2025 edition (previous). It stated that “fortified soy beverages (commonly known as ‘soy milk’) and soy yogurt-which are fortified with calcium, vitamin A, and vitamin D-are included as part of the dairy group.” Other plant “milks,” such as almond, rice, coconut, oat and hemp, “may contain calcium and be consumed as a source of calcium, but they are not included as part of the dairy group,” and “consuming these beverages does not contribute to meeting the dairy group recommendation.”
  • 2025-2030 edition (current since January 2026). The 10-page Guidelines document does not mention soy milk or other plant milks. Its companion chart of daily servings defines the dairy group to include milk, yogurt and cheese and adds: “Lactose-free and lactose-reduced products, as well as fortified dairy alternatives, are also options.”

Neither edition turns a plant milk into dairy milk nutritionally. The practical reading of both is the same: if a plant milk is standing in for dairy, choose a fortified one.

Choosing and cooking with plant milks

For drinking, cereal and coffee

Pick by taste and by what you need from the drink. Soy milk gives the most protein. Oat milk is creamy and slightly sweet. Almond milk is light and mild. Rice milk is thin and sweet-tasting. Coconut beverage tastes faintly of coconut. Sweetened and flavored versions add sugar that counts as added sugar on the label; the guide to natural sweeteners compared explains how those sugars are counted. Whichever you pick, the calories and protein it contributes count toward your daily totals, and how energy balance and TDEE work explains how those add up.

Plant milks can separate or curdle in very hot, acidic coffee. Warming the milk first, or pouring the coffee into the milk rather than the reverse, usually helps; products sold as “barista” versions are made for use in coffee.

For cooking and baking

  • Use unsweetened, unflavored milk for anything savory. Vanilla-flavored milk in a gravy or mashed potatoes is a common mistake.
  • Soy milk is the most dependable for baking and sauces. Its protein helps baked goods brown, and with a spoonful of vinegar or lemon juice it thickens slightly into a buttermilk substitute for pancakes and biscuits.
  • Oat milk bakes well and gives creamy soups and sauces body.
  • Almond and rice milk are thinner; sauces made with them may need a little more thickener.
  • Canned coconut milk, not the carton beverage, is what makes rich curries and dairy-free ice creams; the two are not interchangeable.

In no-cook recipes such as chia pudding, any plant milk works, and the choice mainly changes the flavor and creaminess.

Allergy notes

Soy milk contains soy, almond milk contains tree nuts, and coconut beverage contains coconut. Oat milk suits most people avoiding nuts and soy; for celiac disease, choose one made from certified gluten-free oats. Rice milk is made without soy, nuts or oats; check the ingredient list for anything added. If you are choosing a plant milk for a child, or because of a medical condition, ask your pediatrician, doctor or a registered dietitian which one fits.

Common questions

Which plant milk has the most protein?

Soy milk, by a wide margin among the common options. In USDA FoodData Central records, a cup of unsweetened soy milk has protein close to a cup of 2% dairy milk, while oat, almond, coconut and rice milks have far less. For any other kind, the Nutrition Facts panel gives the protein per cup.

Is oat milk or almond milk better?

They suit different jobs. Unsweetened almond milk is the lowest in calories in USDA data and thin in texture; oat milk is creamier and higher in carbohydrate. Neither has much protein. Their calcium and vitamins depend on fortification, so compare the labels of the products you are choosing between.

Do plant milks have as much calcium as dairy milk?

Fortified ones can. The NIH Office of Dietary Supplements lists calcium-fortified soymilk at 299 mg per cup (23 %DV), and the fortified plant milks in USDA data are in the same broad range as 2% dairy milk, or above it. USDA's record for unfortified soy milk has only a fraction of that, so look for calcium on the Nutrition Facts panel.

Is soy milk part of the dairy group?

In the Dietary Guidelines for Americans, 2020-2025, fortified soy beverages were included in the dairy group and other plant milks were not. The current 2025-2030 Guidelines document does not mention plant milks, while its companion serving chart says fortified dairy alternatives are also options in the dairy group.

Are homemade plant milks as nutritious as store-bought?

Not for calcium, vitamin D or vitamin B12. Homemade soy, oat or nut milk has only what the soybeans, oats or nuts bring, and the calcium, vitamin D and B12 in cartons are mostly added by the manufacturer, as the unfortified soy milk row in the USDA table shows. Homemade milk can taste fresher and contain more of the base ingredient, but if a plant milk is replacing dairy in your diet, a fortified carton fills the gap that homemade does not.

Which plant milk is best for baking?

Unsweetened soy milk is the most dependable all-rounder because its protein helps with browning and structure, and it thickens when mixed with a little vinegar or lemon juice to make a buttermilk substitute. Oat milk also bakes well. Almond and rice milks work but give a slightly less rich result.

Sources

  1. USDA FoodData Central
  2. FDA: Labeling of Plant-Based Milk Alternatives (Draft Guidance)
  3. Dietary Guidelines for Americans, 2020-2025
  4. Daily Servings by Calorie Level (Dietary Guidelines 2025-2030)
  5. NIH Office of Dietary Supplements: Vitamin D

Read next