How to make coconut yogurt at home
How to make thick coconut milk yogurt from a can and a live-culture starter: clean equipment, steady warmth, timing and when to throw a batch out.
Makes About 3 1/2 cups, 7 servings (1/2 cup each)
Ingredients
- 27 fl oz (about 810 g) full-fat canned coconut milk, two 13.5-fluid-ounce (400 ml) cans, shaken well
- 2 tbsp cornstarch
- 2 tsp maple syrup, or sugar
- 1/4 cup (56 g) plain unsweetened coconut yogurt with live and active cultures, or a powdered vegan yogurt starter in the amount its package gives for 1 quart; counted with USDA's only coconut milk yogurt record, which does not say whether it is plain or sweetened
Equipment
- Medium saucepan
- Whisk
- 1-quart glass jar with a lid, washed in hot soapy water and rinsed
- Yogurt maker, multicooker with a yogurt setting, or another steady warm spot
- Clean spoons for stirring and tasting
Method
Wash your hands with soap and warm water. Make sure the jar, lid, saucepan, whisk and spoons are freshly washed in hot soapy water and rinsed, or just out of a dishwasher.
Pour about 1/2 cup of the coconut milk into the saucepan, add the cornstarch and whisk until no lumps remain. Whisk in the rest of the coconut milk and the maple syrup.
Set the pan over medium heat and bring the mixture to a gentle simmer, whisking often, then let it bubble gently for 1 to 2 minutes, until it turns glossy and coats the back of a spoon.
Take the pan off the heat and let it cool, uncovered, until it feels barely warm when you touch a drop to the inside of your wrist, about 45 minutes to 1 hour. Heat kills yogurt cultures, so do not add the starter while the mixture is still hot.
Put the coconut yogurt starter in a small bowl, whisk in a few spoonfuls of the warm coconut mixture to loosen it, then whisk it back into the pan until evenly mixed. If you use a powdered starter, whisk it in following its package.
Pour into the clean jar, cover loosely with the lid and set it somewhere steadily warm: a yogurt maker or a multicooker's yogurt setting, or an oven that is switched off with only the light on. If the starter package gives a temperature, keep to it.
Leave the jar undisturbed until the yogurt smells pleasantly sour, tastes tangy and has thickened slightly, 12 to 24 hours. From 12 hours, taste with a clean spoon each time. If you see pink, orange or fuzzy mold of any color, or it smells rotten, yeasty or unpleasant rather than clean and sour, throw the whole batch away without tasting it.
Stir the yogurt well, stirring any watery layer back in. Cover tightly and refrigerate for at least 4 hours, until cold and thick; it firms a lot as the coconut fat chills. Keep it refrigerated and serve with clean spoons.
Nutrition per serving
| Calories | 290 |
|---|---|
| Total fat | 28 g |
| Saturated fat | 25 g |
| Carbohydrate | 11 g |
| Fiber | 3 g |
| Total sugars | 6 g |
| Protein | 3 g |
| Sodium | 20 mg |
| Calcium | 30 mg |
| Iron | 2 mg |
Per serving, calculated from USDA FoodData Central values for the ingredients and amounts listed. Calories, fat, carbohydrate, fiber, sugars, protein and sodium are rounded with the FDA Nutrition Facts label rules; calcium is shown to the nearest 10 mg and iron to the nearest 0.1 mg. Brands differ, so treat the figures as estimates.
How these numbers were calculated
Each ingredient as weighed for the calculation and the USDA FoodData Central record its nutrients come from. Where USDA has no record for an ingredient (vegan butter, nutritional yeast, coconut sugar), the closest generic record is used and named here.
| Ingredient | Grams | USDA record |
|---|---|---|
| 27 fl oz (about 810 g) full-fat canned coconut milk, two 13.5-fluid-ounce (400 ml) cans, shaken well | 810 g | FDC 2707568: Coconut milk, used in cooking (FNDDS 2021-2023). Weight from: USDA portion '1 fl oz' |
| 2 tbsp cornstarch | 16 g | FDC 169698: Cornstarch (SR Legacy). Weight from: USDA portion '1 cup' (1 cup = 16 tbsp = 48 tsp) |
| 2 tsp maple syrup, or sugar | 13.1 g | FDC 169661: Syrups, maple (SR Legacy). Weight from: USDA portion '1 cup' (1 cup = 16 tbsp = 48 tsp) |
| 1/4 cup (56 g) plain unsweetened coconut yogurt with live and active cultures, or a powdered vegan yogurt starter in the amount its package gives for 1 quart; counted with USDA's only coconut milk yogurt record, which does not say whether it is plain or sweetened | 56.5 g | FDC 2707569: Yogurt, coconut milk (FNDDS 2021-2023). Weight from: USDA portion '1 cup' |
Coconut yogurt is canned coconut milk that has been soured by live yogurt cultures until it tastes tangy and fresh, then chilled until thick and spoonable. Homemade versions usually fail in one of two ways: they stay thin, or they pick up the wrong microbes and spoil. The recipe card above deals with both. A little cornstarch, simmered briefly, gives the yogurt body, and clean equipment, a cooled base and a steady warm spot give the cultures a fair start.
What turns coconut milk into yogurt
Yogurt cultures are bacteria that feed on sugars and turn them into acid. That acid is what gives yogurt its tang. In dairy milk, the rising acidity also makes the milk proteins clump together into a soft gel, which is why dairy yogurt sets in the jar. Coconut milk has less protein than dairy milk and no casein, the dairy protein that does the gelling, so the same process sours it but barely thickens it. That is why this recipe borrows its texture from two other places:
- Cornstarch, whisked in cold and then simmered until glossy. Cornstarch has to reach a simmer to thicken fully, so the short simmer in step 3 is not optional.
- Coconut fat, which firms as it chills. Warm from the jar, the yogurt looks loose; after a night in the refrigerator it is thick enough to hold a spoon.
The small amount of maple syrup gives the cultures some easy sugar to work on. The cultures turn sugar into acid as they work, which is why the finished yogurt tastes tart rather than sweet. The recipe card counts the ingredients as they go into the pan, before fermentation, so it cannot show how much of the sugar the cultures used up.
Choosing a starter
Three kinds of starter work, and they behave differently:
- Store-bought coconut yogurt (used on the card). Pick a plain, unsweetened one whose label says it contains live and active cultures, and check the use-by date. A quarter cup is plenty for this batch.
- Powdered vegan yogurt starter, sold for home yogurt making. Use the amount its package gives for 1 quart and follow any temperature it lists. This is the most predictable option.
- Probiotic capsules, opened and stirred in. Recipes that use them commonly open about two capsules per can, but capsules vary in which cultures they contain and in what amounts, so one brand may sour a batch well and another barely at all. Choose capsules without added prebiotics or other fillers if you try them, and expect to experiment.
There is no way to make yogurt without some starter: plain coconut milk left warm does not reliably turn into yogurt, it just spoils. “Without probiotics” recipes are using one of the first two starters instead of capsules.
The recipe is here for flavor and texture. A home kitchen cannot measure how many live cultures end up in a jar, so no claims are made about what they do once eaten.
Clean equipment and a steady warm spot
The warmth that lets yogurt cultures multiply also suits other microbes, so the method starts with cleanliness. The FDA’s advice for preparing produce, to wash your hands for at least 20 seconds with soap and warm water, is a good first step for any food prep, this one included. Wash the jar, lid, saucepan, whisk and spoons in hot soapy water and rinse them well, or use them straight out of a dishwasher.
Cooling matters as much as cleaning. Heat kills yogurt cultures, so the thickened base has to cool until a drop feels barely warm on the inside of your wrist before the starter goes in. Whisking a few spoonfuls of the warm base into the starter first loosens it so it mixes in evenly.
For the fermentation itself, steady warmth beats a guess:
- A yogurt maker or a multicooker with a yogurt setting holds an even temperature and is the easiest choice.
- An oven switched off with only the light on works in many kitchens, but ovens differ. If your starter gives a temperature, check the spot with a thermometer first.
- A slow cooker is only suitable if it has a yogurt setting; its warm setting can run too hot for the cultures.
- A counter in a cool kitchen usually ferments slowly and unevenly, which leaves more room for something other than yogurt cultures to grow.
Signs it worked, and signs to throw it out
Start tasting at 12 hours with a clean spoon. A batch that worked:
- smells pleasantly sour, a little like dairy yogurt;
- tastes noticeably tangy;
- has thickened slightly and may have a thin watery layer on top, which you simply stir back in.
Throw the whole batch away, without tasting it, if:
- you see pink or orange patches or streaks;
- you see fuzzy mold of any color, even a small spot;
- it smells rotten, yeasty, alcoholic or simply wrong rather than clean and sour.
Do not scrape mold off the top and keep the rest. If a batch seems doubtful, discard it, wash everything well and start again with fresh starter. If you are pregnant or have a weakened immune system, ask your doctor whether homemade fermented foods are a good idea for you.
Heated base or two-ingredient method?
Many online recipes simply stir capsules into a can of coconut milk, unheated, and leave it to ferment. That can work, but the result is thinner, because nothing thickens the milk except the coconut fat. Heating the base, as the card does, has two jobs: it activates the cornstarch, and it gives the cultures a freshly heated start in a clean pan instead of a base that has been poured and handled cold. It also means you can control the cooling, so the starter goes into a base that is warm enough to get going and not so hot that it kills the cultures.
Fixing the texture
- Thin after chilling: the starch may not have reached a simmer, or the coconut milk was a light one. Next time, let the base bubble gently for the full time on the card. For this batch, use it in smoothies or as a pourable topping.
- Grainy or lumpy: coconut fat sometimes sets in flecks. Whisk hard, or blend for a few seconds, then chill again.
- Very firm, almost solid: some brands of coconut milk are richer than others. Stir in a spoonful of plant milk to loosen it.
- Barely sour after 24 hours: the starter was weak or the spot too cool. Do not keep extending the time: a base that has sat warm without souring has had no protection from other microbes, so throw it away and start a new batch with a fresh starter and a warmer, steadier spot.
Making it thicker, or Greek-style
- Richer base: replace one of the two cans of coconut milk with a can of unsweetened coconut cream. The yogurt sets firmer in the refrigerator because it has more fat (and the nutrition on the card no longer applies).
- Straining: spoon the chilled yogurt into a sieve lined with cheesecloth or a coffee filter, set it over a bowl and leave it in the refrigerator until it is as thick as you like. Because the cornstarch holds on to much of the liquid, it drains less than dairy yogurt does.
- Other thickeners: agar, a seaweed-based gelling agent, sets coconut yogurt firm and slightly jelly-like; it has to be boiled to dissolve, so it goes into the base with the cornstarch step, following its package. Gelatin, which some recipes use, is made from animal collagen and is not vegan.
Starting a new batch with a few spoonfuls of a homemade one is less predictable, because each round carries along whatever else got into the jar. A fresh store-bought yogurt or powdered starter for every batch is the reliable choice.
Choosing the coconut milk
Use full-fat canned coconut milk, shaken well so the cream and liquid mix. Light coconut milk ferments, but the result stays thin. Coconut milk sold in cartons as a drink is mostly water with added ingredients, and it will not give a spoonable yogurt; the plant milk comparison explains how those drinks differ from canned coconut milk. Cans that list a gum such as guar gum as well as coconut work fine.
Storing homemade coconut yogurt
Once it is chilled, keep the jar covered in the refrigerator at 40°F or below. USDA’s Food Safety and Inspection Service says perishable food left at room temperature for more than 2 hours (1 hour if the temperature is over 90°F) should be thrown away, so put the jar back in the fridge after serving rather than leaving it on the table. Fermentation is the one deliberate warm stage, which is why the clean equipment, the fresh starter and the throw-it-out signs above matter; once the yogurt has soured and chilled, handle it like any other perishable food. Eat it within 3 to 4 days, the window USDA gives for refrigerated leftovers, and always use a clean spoon so you do not add crumbs or other food to the jar.
Freezing is possible, but thawed coconut yogurt tends to separate and turn grainy, so frozen portions are best blended into smoothies. FoodSafety.gov notes that freezer storage times are for quality only.
Flavoring it
Ferment and chill the yogurt plain, then flavor it, so the cultures are not slowed by fruit acids or large amounts of sugar and you can sweeten each bowl to taste. Stir in vanilla extract and maple syrup for a vanilla yogurt, swirl in mashed berries or a spoonful of jam, or keep it unsweetened for savory uses. With a squeeze of lemon juice and a pinch of salt, the unsweetened yogurt stands in for sour cream on tacos or baked potatoes.
Ways to use it
Spoon it into bowls with fruit and granola, or layer it into an orange and coconut yogurt parfait, adding crunchy toppings at the last minute so they stay crisp. Unsweetened, it also works in savory dishes: stirred with grated cucumber, garlic and salt as a cool dip, or dolloped onto a spicy curry or vegan bean chili. It is one of a handful of kitchen basics, like homemade cauliflower rice, that are easy to make ahead and use through the week.
Allergy and ingredient notes
This recipe is built on coconut, so anyone who avoids coconut should not make it. If you use a store-bought yogurt as the starter, read its label as well, since some plant-based yogurts contain other ingredients, such as soy or nuts. Apart from whatever the starter yogurt contains, the recipe has no dairy, eggs, wheat, peanuts, soy or sesame.
Common questions
Why is my homemade coconut yogurt runny?
Coconut milk has less protein than dairy milk and none of the casein that makes dairy yogurt gel, so it does not set the way dairy yogurt does. The thickness comes from the cornstarch and from the coconut fat firming in the refrigerator. Light coconut milk, skipping the simmer that activates the starch, or tasting it before it has chilled for at least 4 hours all give a thin result.
Can I use probiotic capsules to make coconut yogurt?
Some cooks open probiotic capsules and stir the powder in as a starter. Capsules differ in which cultures they contain and how much, so results vary from brand to brand and batch to batch. A spoonful of plain coconut yogurt labeled with live and active cultures, or a powdered starter sold for making yogurt, gives more predictable results.
How do I know if my coconut yogurt has gone bad?
Throw it out if you see pink, orange or fuzzy mold of any color, or if it smells rotten, yeasty or unpleasant instead of clean and sour. Do not scrape off the mold and eat the rest, and do not taste a batch to decide. When in doubt, discard it.
How long does homemade coconut yogurt last in the fridge?
Keep it covered at 40°F or below and eat it within 3 to 4 days, the window USDA gives for refrigerated leftovers. Use a clean spoon every time you take some out.
Can I make coconut yogurt without heating the coconut milk?
Yes, many recipes stir a starter into cold canned coconut milk and ferment it as it is, but the yogurt comes out thinner because nothing thickens it except the fat. Heating the base, as on the card, activates the cornstarch and lets you add the starter at the right warmth.
Can I make coconut yogurt without a yogurt maker?
Yes. Any spot that stays steadily warm works, such as an oven that is switched off with only the light on, or a multicooker with a yogurt setting. Ovens vary, so if your starter package gives an incubation temperature, check the spot with a thermometer.
Sources
Read next
Coconut whipped cream
How to make coconut whipped cream: chilling the can, scooping off the cream, why some cans will not whip, sweetening, keeping it stable, and storing it.
How to press tofu, and when you don't need to
How to press tofu with a towel and weight or a press, which tofu needs it and which never does, freezing for chew, crisp baking and frying, and storage.
How to make cauliflower rice that is fluffy, not mushy
How to make cauliflower rice with a box grater or food processor, cook it dry in a skillet or roast it, season it, freeze it and avoid mushy, watery rice.
Vegan pistachio ice cream
A coconut-milk pistachio ice cream with real pistachio flavor and no green dye: blending the nuts, a chilled base that churns smooth, plus a no-churn method.
Vegan butter pecan ice cream with caramel
Dairy-free butter pecan ice cream: pecans toasted in vegan butter, a brown sugar coconut-milk base and a cold coconut caramel swirl. Churned or no-churn.